Share
8th December 2022
02:13pm GMT
Pundits from RTÉ and ITV make up the majority of the top eight, with the BBC's offering, so far, not standing out to the same extent.
They have had interesting guests, such as Vincent Kompany and Mauricio Pochettino, but so far, we have not seen enough of them on our screens.
Here are our top eight pundits ahead of the quarter-finals.
8. Richie Sadlier - RTÉ.
Sadlier is one of the most informed pundits on RTÉ and is clearly well-researched on every team he has been tasked with covering.
7. Karen Carney - ITV.
Carney has been one of ITV's better pundits, offering intelligent insight and a refreshing balance next to the more forthright pundits on the station.
6. Kevin Doyle - RTÉ.
Doyle has been one of RTÉ's best pundits. The former Ireland striker is analytical and unafraid to stick his neck on the line by making a prediction.
https://twitter.com/SportsJOEdotie/status/1600186072922611712
5. Gary Neville - ITV.
Neville is still one of the best pundits covering the game, but he hasn't always excelled in the shorter format of covering tournament football on commercial television.
Neville doesn't have the space to analyse matches in-depth the way he does on Sky Sports, and the tournament format definitely better suits soundbite punditry.
After a shaky start, however, Neville has grown into the tournament and his prediction that Spain's lack of firepower would cost them was proved correct. He also spoke well about Cristiano Ronaldo after his former teammate was dropped by Portugal.
4. Damien Duff - RTÉ.
Duff returned to the RTÉ panel for England's final group game against Wales and gave the station's coverage a much-needed boost.
Duff, at his best, combines the best attributes of Eamon Dunphy and John Giles, two punditry legends. Like Giles, Duff is analytical, knowledgable and tactically excellent.
Like Dunphy, Duff is also forthright and controversial and prepared strongly state an opinion. Duff is no-nonsense, direct and doesn't pull any punches.
https://twitter.com/SportsJOEdotie/status/1597709171452960771
3. Didi Hamann - RTÉ.
Hamann is knowledgeable and a straight shooter.
The German doesn't resort to easy soundbites or lazy takes and presents his views in a rational and concise manner.
Hamann is a breath of fresh air for analytical football punditry compared to some of the more jingoistic stylings elsewhere.
https://twitter.com/SportsJOEdotie/status/1600041100093243392
2. Graeme Souness - ITV.
Souness isn't to everyone's tastes, and he may be wrong more than he is right with his opinions on players and teams, but he has performed well in the shorter, snappier pace of World Cup TV.
The Scot offers viewers a reference point, an opinion to disagree with, and there is value in this. Someone has to be the bad guy.
Souness also has great chemistry with Keane, and their spat at half-time of Argentina versus Saudi Arabia was a great watch.
1. Roy Keane - ITV.
Roy Keane has been the star pundit of the tournament so far. The Irishman is perfect for the quick-paced nature of the World Cup on TV, where there were four matches a day for the first 10 days of the tournament.
Keane doesn't provide searing tactical insight, he won't tell you how a match was won and lost in intricate detail. Yet, no pundit is better at simplifying an issue or topic.
Keane's comments about Qatar also made an impact on a greater scale than so many of his contemporaries because he got to the heart of the issue in a few sentences.
"They shouldn’t have the World Cup here," The Irishman said. "You can’t treat people like that... The bottom line is, we are talking about common decency, how you treat people."
Keane is box office, and his forthright views, combined with his wit, make for excellent TV.
Explore more on these topics:
