Share
11th May 2021
06:19pm BST
In his IOL column, Keohane described Lions captain Alun Wyn Jones [pictured above] as a "plodder" who was selected on past glories and his familiarity to Gatland, the former Wales coach. Taking aim at more than a few of the squad, he declared:
'The rallying cry from within the Lions rugby fraternity is that Gatland is fighting fire with fire, bringing beasts to the Republic to conquer the world champion Springboks. But I disagree. Gatland has picked hobbits to be giant slayers and he has far too many Neville Nobodies in his squad of 37.'The Pundits Podcast, which often features a mix of South African rugby correspondents, coaches and supporters, was equally bullish.
"We have the Lions squad," said Kruger, "and I'm going to be controversial from the get-go, here. I think it's bang average."Jared Wright argued that toss, but said the fact that Gatland selected eight Scottish players - that nation's biggest contingent since 1989 - was "mind-blowing". "Most of them deserve to be there," he added. "The only guy that I'd say sticks out as a 50/50 call for me is Zander Fagerson. It's just because I think Kyle Sinckler is a better tighthead." Once he heard that, Kruger predicted the Springboks tight five would seriously rough up their Lions counterparts. Later in the show, he asked his panel:
"Are you worried about their pack? Because, at this moment in time, to be honest with you, I think we bully them if our pack guys are on top form... if the guys are physically fit and raring to go, I think we bully them. I don't think they have an answer to us."There was praise for Tadhg Furlong, Courtney Lawes and Maro Itoje, during the show, but Wright feels England flanker Sam Underhill and Ireland lock James Ryan should have made the touring squad. On his recent House of Rugby Ireland appearance [LISTEN from 26:30 below], South African rugby correspondent Craig Ray gave a balanced take on Gatland's squad choices. "Looking at some of the omissions," says Craig, who is editor at The Daily Maverick, "Johnny Sexton is a big surprise. "He's a big name. I know he's had his injury problems and his form hasn't exactly been great, but he's been there and done it. So I'm quite surprised that he isn't at least in the broader squad.
"James Ryan is the other big one. A good, tough forward. I guess someone like Courtney Lawes is a physical character, too, so it probably came down to that call. "And the rest, I guess, are such close calls. There's a few, here and there, that you can argue about. Not knowing enough about the players' club form, I reckon Gatland has pretty much got it spot on."Others in South Africa, including Springbok legend Victor Matfield, wondered where Manu Tuilagi and Billy Vunipola were while Kruger and the Pundits Podcast crew reckoned Kyle Sinckler should have made the cut. It will be a couple of months before Erasmus and Jacques Nienaber, the Springboks head coach, have to nail their squad selection colours to the mast. When they do, expect the same hot takes from the northern hemisphere experts, and those that are catching their soundbites around water-coolers, and Zoom chats.
Explore more on these topics:
